Suzy Sheer at the Oxford Art Factory, 16/10/26
Sina Carbone reviews …
If you had happened to pass OAF and bum a durry from one of the many waxed-denim clad Suzy Sheer goers loitering on Oxford Street post-gig, you would be one confused bystander. After an hour-long set and finally released to the street—under the white lights of fetishwear storefronts, micro-news agencies and kebab shops—I can’t really decide if I care about Suzy Sheer anymore. And, when I ask around, it seems no one else can make up their mind either.
Suzy Sheer was one of the first artists I discovered in early 2024 belonging to the critically maligned cohort of indie sleaze revivalists. The same TikToks that mourned the mainstreamification of 2Hollis pressed Chrome Hearts-stacked fingers to their lips and begged their FYPs to keep Suzy Sheer a secret.
Ironically, these were the very same videos that had me dive into the bands’ first album Euphoriphilia. As their name suggests, glittery and glitchy production prevails. Seraphic vocal harmonies dodge chunky electronic stabs through loops that swell and shrink like healthy lungs. The samples are smart and become something wholly new. At the time it was exciting and Suzy Sheer were messianic for those who cared about the old electroclash and indie dance scenes. But as years pass, and the scene inflates with others rehashing the same beats of a dead era, I can’t help but want more. 2026’s Pure Pulse, Slow Decay, Soft Release leaves me underwhelmed. Rare gem ‘No Surprise’ mashes together acoustic guitar and electronic stutters, but the rest of the album sounds like the homogenous slab of nostalgiabait that is plaguing the underground.
Rare gem ‘No Surprise’ mashes together acoustic guitar and electronic stutters, but the rest of the album sounds like the homogenous slab of nostalgiabait that is plaguing the underground.
Misgivings aside, I remained hopeful that Suzy Sheer could redeem themselves live. This show marks the second time Suzy Sheer has ever visited Sydney, and only 11 months since their Oxford Art Factory debut in a coheadline with Damon R. From what I had heard, this show was not one to miss, and being the first musical instalment in 2026’s Surplus Festival, I had lofty expectations.
There was much to love about the performance. The staging was an intoxicating wash of white light cast over three silhouettes, only breaking into CMYK during an ecstatic encore of ‘Blissed’, which will undeniably be Suzy Sheer’s enduring classic. The band persisted in a languid slush of electronica that was rarely broken by any meaningful crowd interaction, allowing us to lavish in sonic twinkles while pressing into a crowd of mutual swayers. The dancefloor remained sustained although not particularly inspired until the encore of recognisables, which can be counted a feat in this Sydney scene regardless.
the band’s languid slush of electronica was rarely broken by any meaningful crowd interaction, allowing us to lavish in sonic twinkles while pressing into a crowd of mutual swayers.
Aside from the positives, technical errors and meandering but ultimately meaningless improvisations plagued an otherwise decent set, souring the experience and coming off as slightly amateurish. I was left confused, satisfied but not quite as moved as I anticipated. Reaching out to fellow goers for corroboration, each person had a different muddled interpretation of the happenings. Some liked the beginning but were lost and jaded on the way to the encore. Others drew contrasts between this performance and their debut Sydney show, but shrugged that this time was “nothing super special.” Among things cited for the mediocrity of the show were stage presence, sound engineering, setlist, and crowd energy, each bystander having a completely separate take on why the gig fell flat, with the only common denominator being a diminished appreciation for the outfit. Others were just glad to be there. Well, I was glad to be there, but knowing their previous recording heights, I can’t help but wish Suzy Sheer had more to give live.
It is my opinion that Suzy Sheer should wait more than 11 months to return to Australia and cut their teeth locally until they have a more seasoned live offering. In an oversaturated market, I hope Suzy Sheer can recapture what it was that made their debut efforts so enticing and take it somewhere new. And then take it back here.
Post a comment